How to Choose the Right Cruise
Each year, I attend the Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA) seminar, a two-day event where 28 different cruise lines present their latest ships, itineraries, and innovations. Some years the focus is on new ship launches, other years it’s about each cruise line’s unique selling points, and sometimes it’s about sustainability and the future of cruising.
But no matter the focus, one thing remains clear:
🌟 There is truly a cruise for everyone!
Many people assume cruising is only for retirees or families, but that couldn’t be further from the truth. Whether you’re a solo traveller looking for adventure, a couple wanting a romantic getaway, a group of friends seeking fun, or a family needing an all-in-one holiday, the perfect cruise is out there for you.
The challenge? Finding the one that best suits your style, interests, and expectations. And that’s where this series of articles comes in!
🕵 My job as a cruise specialist isn’t just to book your cabin—it’s to help you find your perfect match at sea.
Which Cruise Type Suits You Best?
With so many cruise lines, ships, and itineraries to choose from, it can be overwhelming to find the right one. But if you break it down by cruise type, ship size, and travel style, it becomes much easier to navigate.
Ocean, River, or Expedition – What’s Your Style?
Ocean Cruises – If you love the idea of sailing across vast open waters, waking up to a new destination every day, and enjoying endless entertainment, an ocean cruise is for you. Whether it's the Caribbean, the Mediterranean, or Alaska, these cruises take you to multiple ports while offering world-class dining, Broadway-style shows, and activities for all ages.
River Cruises – Perfect for those who love slow travel and cultural immersion. River cruises glide through historic waterways like the Danube, Rhine, Mekong, and Nile, stopping at charming towns and major cities along the way. Instead of spending days at sea, you're constantly surrounded by picturesque landscapes and have the chance to explore a new destination daily.
A good way to think of it is that an ocean cruise takes you across the open seas to many different places &/or countries and typically includes days at sea, whereas a river cruise takes you through a country (or countries) offering direct access to villages & towns along the way.
Expedition Cruises – If you crave adventure and exploration, expedition cruises take you to the most remote and untouched destinations on Earth. Think Antarctica, the Galápagos Islands, the Arctic Circle, and the Kimberley region. These smaller ships come equipped with Zodiacs for shore landings, expert guides, and unique wildlife encounters.
Size Matters – Choosing the Right Ship
The size of the ship plays a major role in the experience you'll have onboard.
Mega Ships (5,000+ passengers) – The Floating Resorts
If you love variety, entertainment, and a lively atmosphere, mega-ships like Royal Caribbean’s Star of the Seas are packed with activities, from surf simulators and skydiving simulators to Broadway-style shows and waterparks. Great for families, multigenerational travellers, and thrill-seekers.
Large Ships (2,700-4,999 passengers) – Big Experiences, Less Crowds
Large ships balance entertainment with more refined experiences. Think the Star Princess or Celebrity XCel, where you still get plenty of dining options, entertainment, and activities but with a slightly more upscale feel.
Mid-Size Ships (1,600-2,699 passengers) – A Happy Medium
Mid-size ships, like those from Holland America or Oceania, cater to those who enjoy elegant, relaxed cruising with quality dining and enrichment programs. These ships often offer fewer crowds while still providing entertainment and onboard amenities.
Small Ships (Under 800 passengers) – Intimate & Immersive
If you prefer a more personal, exclusive experience, small-ship cruising is for you. Luxury cruise brands like Silversea, Seabourn, and Ponant focus on fine dining, personalized service, and immersive cultural experiences. These ships often visit off-the-beaten-path destinations that larger ships can’t reach.
Special Consideration: Expedition Cruising & The Antarctica 500, 200, 100 Rule
When it comes to expedition cruising—especially in Antarctica—ship size is even more critical. The International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators (IAATO) enforces strict rules to protect the fragile ecosystem and limit the number of visitors at any given time.
Here’s what you need to know about the 500, 200, 100 rule for Antarctic landings:
🚢 Ships with more than 500 passengers: Cannot make landings in Antarctica. Guests can enjoy breathtaking views from the ship, but they won't set foot on land.
🚢 Ships with 200-500 passengers: Limited shore landings in specific areas. Passengers may get off the ship, but access is more restricted due to environmental regulations.
🚢 Ships with fewer than 200 passengers: The best option for a true Antarctic experience! These vessels can access smaller fjords and allow all passengers to participate in shore landings, giving you a more immersive experience.
👥 A maximum of 100 passengers can be ashore at any one time in most landing zones, ensuring minimal impact on the environment.
Why This Matters
If visiting Antarctica is on your bucket list and you want to step foot on the continent, choosing a small expedition ship (under 200 passengers) is crucial. These ships, like those from Aurora Expeditions, Quark Expeditions, and Ponant, provide specialist guides, Zodiac excursions, and wildlife encounters—making your Antarctic adventure truly unforgettable.
What’s Your Travel Style?
Not all cruise lines are created equal—each caters to a specific type of traveller. Below you will find links to a series of articles that break down your choices into different categories of cruising:
🔗  Ultra-Luxury & Boutique Cruising – For lovers of space, elegance and curated experiences.
🔗  Expedition & Adventure Cruising – For explorers, wildlife watchers and travellers seeking remote wilderness.
🔗  River Cruising & Cultural Immersion – For travellers who like to take it show, diving into the food, wine and history of a region.
🔗  Ocean Cruising – For families, couples, first-timers, fun-seekers, & solo travellers.
🔗  Small Ship & Enrichment-Focused Cruising – For solos, culture lovers and lifelong learners.
Ocean Extensions & Crossover Brands – For those ready to try something different, without losing the small-ship feel. The brands include PONANT & Seabourn.
Why Work With a CLIA Master Cruise Consultant?
There are so many cruise options out there that it can feel overwhelming. With so many options, how do you choose?
As a CLIA-accredited Master Cruise Consultant, I have first-hand experience with cruise lines, ships, and destinations, allowing me to match you with the perfect cruise.
And that’s exactly why I created this series—to give you insight, clarity, and confidence when it comes to choosing your next (or first!) cruise.
What I Offer
ðŸ§Â Personalised Guidance – No generic suggestions! I take the time to understand your preferences and match you with the ideal cruise.
💎 Exclusive Deals – I have access to industry-only offers, pre-sale bookings, and hidden perks.
🧘 Stress-Free Planning – From cabin selection to shore excursions, I handle all the details so you can just enjoy the experience.
🚢 Cruising is an investment in unforgettable memories—let’s make sure you get the right experience for you!
Meet Your Cruise Specialist, Philip
As a CLIA Top 100 Master Cruise Consultant in Australia, my accreditation provides me with specialist knowledge in the luxury cruise space, allowing me to offer expert guidance on selecting the perfect voyage. Read More
FAQs About Choosing the Right Cruise
1. How do I choose the right cruise for my travel style?
Start by deciding what kind of experience you want. Ocean cruises suit travellers who love variety and entertainment, river cruises focus on culture and relaxation, and expedition cruises appeal to adventure seekers exploring remote destinations.
2. What size cruise ship should I choose?
Ship size affects atmosphere and amenities. Mega ships offer lively entertainment and activities for families, while small ships provide a more personal and immersive experience. Mid-size ships are ideal for travellers seeking balance between space, comfort, and enrichment.
3. What is the best cruise line for first-time cruisers?
The best cruise line depends on your interests and budget. Lines like Royal Caribbean and Celebrity are great for first-timers seeking entertainment and comfort, while premium and small-ship lines such as Oceania or Seabourn cater to travellers wanting a relaxed, refined experience.
4. What is the Antarctica 500, 200, 100 rule?
This rule governs how many passengers can land ashore at once. Ships with more than 500 passengers cannot make landings, while smaller expedition ships under 200 passengers allow everyone the chance to explore the continent safely and responsibly.
5. Why should I use a CLIA Master Cruise Consultant?
A CLIA-accredited consultant offers expert insight, exclusive deals, and first-hand experience across cruise lines and destinations. They match your preferences with the ideal cruise and manage all the planning, giving you confidence and peace of mind.
Share this on Social Media